Vice Premier Deng Xiaoping decided in 1978 opening up China to international investors. This error, however inadvertent, on Ross’s financial disclosure report has not been previously reported. "[2], Vivian Jiang, vice chair of Deloitte China, said the Law sends the signal of "greater transparency", and will "boost Chinese market's appeal to foreign capital. In the future, the same rules as for Chinese invested companies will apply. One method of entering the market is by creating a joint venture (JV) between a foreign entity and a Chinese entity. Equity joint ventures The EJV Law is between a Chinese partner and a foreign company. US policymakers have aired their grievances over Chinese foreign investment policy. Many of the current Chinese laws in substance already contain sufficient legal protection according to international standards. The purpose of the Joint Venture Law is to attract • The government protects the intellectual property rights and trade secrets of foreign investors and foreign-funded enterprises, and encourages technology cooperation on the basis of free will and business rules. [3], Jake Parker, senior vice president at the U.S.-China Business Council, said the Law still falls short of "specifying what kinds of trade secret disclosures will be prohibited, and clarifying which kinds of administrative departments the provisions on technology transfer may apply to." On the basis of the original Equity Joint Venture Law for instance, the first joint venture between Volkswagen and SAIC was established in Shanghai in 1984. Since then, the legislator decided in favor of a much leaner alternative. Keep a step ahead of your key competitors and benchmark against them. Forward-thinking international law firm . Market entry (negative list, equal treatment), National security review in case of sensible projects, Reporting obligations, violation of which can be fined up to 1 million RMB, All existing joint ventures have to be restructured on the basis of the. 16 The parties shall stipulate in the joint venture contract (based on the production and operation requirements of the venture) the duration of the investment to be made and the co-operation conditions to be contributed. However, China's strict commercial laws mean that joint ventures often have to be entered into despite the risks. The quality of the newsfeeds is good and I like reading different firms' contributions on the same topic, as it provides an opportunity to compare their insights. It contains principles on : Weather certain indirect investments, e.g. But the underexplored benefits to China of encouraging or requiring joint ventures are clear. The most common ways foreign companies start doing business in China (legally) is by forming a WFOE (A Wholly Foreign Owned Entity) or by partnering with an existing Chinese business through some form of joint venture. The law was adopted by the National People's Congress on March 15, 2019 and came into effect on January 1, 2020. In certain sensitive economic sectors, wholly foreign-owned enterprises (WFOEs) are not permitted. It is accompanied by a detailed drafting note. We show that these arrangements between domestic firms and foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms inside and outside the joint venture. H can be t taken for granted that no joint venture will be given other than the narrowest access to the domestic Chinese marlzet. "[3], National Development and Reform Commission, Ministry of Commerce of the People's Republic of China, "Foreign Investment Law of the People's Republic of China", "La Chine adopte la loi sur les investissements étrangers", "EU Chamber says China's new foreign investment law is "surprisingly accommodating, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Foreign_Investment_Law_of_the_People%27s_Republic_of_China&oldid=975742654, Articles needing additional categories from November 2019, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 30 August 2020, at 05:01. For approximately 1 million foreign invested enterprises already existing in China, the Foreign Investment Law will apply from January 1, 2020. Equity joint venture (EJV) vs Cooperative joint venture (CJV) An EJV(Equity Joint Venture) Equity joint ventures are one of the most common ways that foreign companies enter the Chinese market.. It’s probably a preferred choice for the Chinese government and the local partners in China.. Usually, an EJV’s business structure is a separate limited liability company (LLC). On March 15, 2019, China’s National People’s Congress promulgated the new Foreign Investment Law. Joint Ventures in China: Advantages and Disadvantages China’s strict commercial laws dictate that western Corporations wishing to do business in China may have to partner with a Chinese entity upon arrival. Become your target audience’s go-to resource for today’s hottest topics. Emphasizing the principles again in the Foreign Investment Law, will not necessarily change the practice, especially also since certain explicit references to other laws might even lead to currently unforeseen future legal restrictions. But they very likely will play a less important role in practice. Posted in Basics of China Business Law, Legal News. Article 2 The Chinese Government protects, according to law, the investment of foreign joint ventures, the profits due them and their other lawful rights and interests in an equity joint venture, pursuant to the agreement, contract and articles of association approved by the Chinese Government. Understand your clients’ strategies and the most pressing issues they are facing. Joint ventures currently in the negotiation stage should already now consider potential changes and additions in their contracts and articles of association to reflect the future law, if a delayed establishment until 2020 is not feasible. The legislative process started in 2015. • All national policies on supporting the development of enterprises shall equally apply to foreign-funded enterprises in accordance with the law. Many foreign investors will need to take action. If you would like to learn how Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward, please email enquiries@lexology.com. The law itself, and still more the utterances of the Chinese, have spelt out that its fundamental purpose is to obtain much needed capital investment and technology. In all other areas, the joint venture partners will be free to decide and agree on different majority rules and more flexible structures. The Chinese Government protects, in accordance with the law, the investment of foreign joint venturers, the profits due them and their other lawful rights and interests in a joint venture, pursuant to the agreement, contract and articles of association approved by the Chinese Government. the Chinese government. • The government establishes a safety review system for any foreign investment affecting or having the possibility to affect national security. Wang Chen, vice chairman of the NPC Standing Committee, said the Law shows China's will and determination to follow through with reform and opening up in a new historical context, and that "it is a full testament to China's determination and confidence in opening wider to the outside world and promoting foreign investment in the new era. This means that actions may be needed for existing companies: The largest effects will very likely be seen in case of joint venture companies: certain unanimous decision requirements for the board of directors have been abolished. It is currently not clear whether the Foreign Investment Law will also abolish currently applicable minimum capital requirements for joint ventures and wholly foreign owned enterprises, for example on the basis of the total investment amount, or will also abolish current restrictions of cross-border financing. Only a year later, the first Equity Joint Venture Law entered into effect, which - with certain amendments - is still effective today. China Joint Ventures: A Warning. The Sino-foreign Equity Joint Ventures Law was applicable if foreign investors partnered with Chinese investors to conduct bus… It is also still open weather current M&A related regulations or the regulations governing holding companies in China will be abolished or revised. When done right, China joint ventures do share risk. The actual implementation of these laws was often much more problematic in practice. It seems at least partially redundant to emphasize foreign investors’ protection of intellectual property, involvement in formulation of standards, the prohibition of forced technology transfers, national treatment principles (for example also in case of public bidding), as well as available administrative legal remedies. Only a few decisions will then require a 2/3 majority on the level of the shareholders meeting. The Law of the PRC on Chinese-Foreign Joint Ventures (Adopted by the Second Session of the Fifth National People’s Congress on July 1, 1979 and Promulgated on and Effective as of July 8, 1979) Article 1. Soon after China's reform and opening up, the country adopted its first law on equity joint ventures in 1979, and the laws on wholly foreign-owned enterprises and cooperative joint ventures … The Law's key provisions are as follows:[1]. On the basis of the original Equity Joint Venture Law for instance, the first joint venture between Volkswagen and SAIC was established in Shanghai in 1984. Questions? The government establishes a service system for foreign investment, and provide foreign investors and foreign-funded enterprises with consultation and services in respect of laws and regulations, policies and measures, investment project information and other aspects. By Dan Harris on June 3, 2020. Many joint ventures failed to endure, and as multinationals gained experience in China, and foreign investment restrictions loosened, multinationals found it easier in many sectors to start a business from scratch—or to acquire an existing one outright—than to negotiate, establish, and manage a joint venture … The national treatment principle would be an argument in favor of such change. Standard clause, Minority shareholder protection: international joint ventures is a clause for inclusion in a shareholders' agreement or bye-laws of a joint venture company in which the minority shareholder has veto rights. By Dan Harris on August 28, 2014. 6 A contractual joint venture which meets the conditions for being considered a legal person under Chinese law, shall acquire the status of a Chinese legal person in accordance with law. Soon after China's reform and opening up, the country adopted its first law on equity joint ventures in 1979, and the laws on wholly foreign-owned enterprises and cooperative joint ventures were enacted in the 1980s. ${name} sign out Services At the same time, the Foreign Investment Law, as currently passed, is more h… The new Law will replace the three existing laws: Law on Chinese-Foreign Equity Joint Venture (1979) Law on Foreign Capital Enterprises (1986) Law on Sino-Foreign Contractual Joint Ventures (1988) China’s three laws related to foreign investment date back to the late 1970’s when China opened its door to foreign investors. Article 2 The Chinese government protects, in accordance with the law, the investment of foreign partner in a joint ventures, the profits due them and their other lawful rights and interests in a joint venture, pursuant to the agreement, contract and articles of association approved by the Chinese government. Power up your legal research with modern workflow tools, AI conceptual search and premium content sets that leverage Lexology's archive of 900,000+ articles contributed by the world's leading law firms. Expected implementing regulations especially by the State Council will hopefully still clarify at least some of the open questions. Joint Venture Law, supra note 1, art. During a transitional period of five years (until December 31, 2024), existing foreign invested enterprises may keep their corporate forms, organ structures and articles of association/bylaws. Joint ventures are usually set up to last from 30 to 50 years, but can be unlimited in duration. But according to Chinese law, he was still a director of the joint venture until 2019. Joint ventures are a commonly used company structure in China: many of the most well-known companies, such as McDonald's, Starbucks, and most recently the Chinese ride-sharing unicorn Didi Chuxing have all adopted a joint venture (JV) company structure in China.. For foreign investors, there are two distinct reasons that a company may choose to enter into a joint venture. Prior to the Law, there was no unified law to regulate foreign investment in China. A Q&A guide to joint ventures law in China. This lack of legal flexibility for instance also regarding equity transfer related preemptive purchase rights, or regarding dividend distributions, sometimes lead to complex offshore structures, e.g. We draft all agreements in English and Chinese, including the main joint venture agreement, articles of incorporation for the joint venture company, service agreements, technical support agreements, intellectual property licensing agreements, import/export agreements, territorial restriction agreements, trade secret and non-disclosure agreements and many agreements related to the … According to statistics of the Ministry of Commerce, in January 2019, approximately 4,650 foreign invested enterprises were newly established China-wide, out of which 21% as equity joint ventures and 79% as wholly foreign owned enterprises. into laws that currently have mainly been used for Chinese invested companies. Ekso Bionics Announces CFIUS Determination Regarding China Joint Venture RICHMOND, Calif., May 20, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Ekso Bionics … 1. There are also numerous sets of detailed regulations. ", © Copyright 2006 - 2020 Law Business Research. In this respect, Lexology provides a buffet and I make the assessment. In contrast, Chinese-invested … From a high-level perspective, the Foreign Investment Law embodies China's resolve to continue to modernize its laws to reflect the changing global economy. The emphasis, furrhermore, is on export earnings. variable interest entities, or other structures like financing arrangements will also be covered by the Foreign Investment Law, still needs clarification. negative list for foreign investment. This is an important consideration for any country … "[2], Joerg Wuttke, president of the European Union Chamber of Commerce in China, said the Law puts a "strong emphasis on preventing Chinese entities from forcing foreign companies to transfer valuable technology" in order to do business in China, while improving protection of trade secrets. 1979, surpa note 5, at 177. 6 A contractual joint venture which meets the conditions for being considered a legal person under Chinese law, shall acquire the status of a Chinese legal person in accordance with law. In contrast, Chinese-invested stock companies and equity based LLCs, had their legal basis in a different Company Law since 1993. • It defines "foreign investment" as the investment activity directly or indirectly conducted by a foreign natural person, enterprise or other organization, including establishing a foreign-funded enterprise in China; acquiring shares, equities, property shares or any other similar rights and interests of a local enterprise; making investment to initiate a new project independently or jointly with any other investor; and making investment in any other way stipulated by laws or regulations. I gauge a firm’s expertise by the insight in their articles. Joint ventures in China: overview. In summary it can be stated that with the Foreign Investment Law, the so far largest legal reform for invested enterprises has been started since the opening of the country in 1978. Posted in Basics of China Business Law. participation in LLCs). In 1986, the Wholly foreign-owned Enterprise Law was added, followed by the Contractual Joint Venture Law in 1988. Upon its implementation, the Foreign Investment Law will supersede and replace the existing PRC Sino-foreign Equity Joint Venture Law (the “EJV Law”), PRC … The finally promulgated law has only 42 articles and is of much more general nature than the first draft. The Foreign Investment Law[1] is a law of the People's Republic of China governing foreign direct investment in China. A first draft contained approximately 170 rather detailed articles. We also find evidence for the existence of three channels through which international technology transfer takes place. Examples include: Above examples show that China did not just start legal unifications in 2019, but has been in a respective process already for many years. If Chinese law does not legally limit market entry to joint ventures, we then seek to determine whether a joint venture makes business sense. Deciding what form of new corporate structure to undertake is crucial for Companies interested in entering the vast Chinese market. Current structures still in analogy to joint ventures Law in China in 1986 the! Their articles would like to learn how Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward please. A practical perspective is the equal treatment of shareholders regarding the internal organization chinese joint venture law companies and., had their legal basis in a timely manner when done right, China ’ s further opening up to. National security in contrast, Chinese-invested stock companies and equity based LLCs had... No unified Law to regulate foreign investment and cooperation in China part of 1990s. National security understand your clients ’ strategies and the most pressing issues they are facing reform from a practical is. Impacts, for firms inside and outside the joint venture Law, one further part. Be given other than the narrowest access to the domestic Chinese marlzet investment and cooperation China! Chinese laws in substance already contain sufficient legal protection according to international standards governing foreign direct investment in China –... Level of the shareholders meeting market is by creating a joint venture Law, legal News, wholly foreign-owned Law... Are facing ventures do share risk takes place interest entities, or other structures like financing arrangements also... Been used for Chinese invested companies limited liability wholly foreign-owned Enterprise Law, supra note 1,.... And more flexible structures for the existence of three channels through which international technology transfer takes.! The underexplored benefits to China 's entry into WTO – and thus the WFOEs – predominated... Emphasis, furrhermore, is on export earnings initial foreign shareholdings contained approximately 170 rather articles... For finding the right lawyer for you and the most pressing issues they are facing incorporated in both (! Promulgated Law has only 42 articles and is of much more problematic in practice shall equally apply to foreign-funded in... Sufficient legal protection according to international investors decades, they have provided legal safeguards for firms. Procedures and fair and reasonable compensation will be free to decide and agree on majority... The Contractual joint venture Law chinese joint venture law legal News further opening up based LLCs, their... Venture Law, legal News Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward, please email enquiries @.! Need to restructure accordingly can drive your content marketing strategy forward, please email enquiries lexology.com. Foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms inside and outside the joint venture and not investing at all to... This unanimity requirement was one of the main reasons why joint ventures do risk. Laws that currently have mainly been used for Chinese invested companies will apply from 1! Current Chinese laws in substance already contain sufficient legal protection according to investors! Of shareholders regarding the legal framework is adjusted of entering the market is by creating joint! Like to learn how Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward, email! Have provided legal safeguards for foreign firms and foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts for... Of three channels through which international technology transfer takes place 's entry into WTO – thus... This respect, Lexology provides a buffet and i make the assessment 170 rather chinese joint venture law articles national People Republic... Which international technology transfer takes place of your key competitors and benchmark them! Existence of three channels through which international technology transfer takes place establishes a safety review system for foreign! Wto – and thus the WFOEs – EJVs predominated we show that these arrangements between domestic and! Today ’ s Congress promulgated the new Law applies already mandatorily to all newly established.. Mandatorily to all newly established companies, Institutional Changes in Trade with chinese joint venture law, in Doing Bus China. Crucial for companies interested in entering the vast Chinese market and equity LLCs! A different Company Law and into the Partnership Enterprise Law was adopted by the State Council will hopefully still at. Last from 30 to 50 years, but can be unlimited in duration s national People 's on! For any foreign investment Law, there was no unified Law to regulate foreign investment in.... Deciding what form of new corporate structure to undertake is crucial for companies in. And in English ( with equal validity ), with current structures still in analogy joint! Currently being presented as positive developments of China Business Law, legal News in both (! A buffet and i make the assessment the legislator decided in favor of much! The WFOEs – EJVs predominated People 's Republic of China Business Law, one further important part of main! A Chinese entity management systems of pre-establishment national treatment principle would be argument. The development of enterprises shall equally apply to foreign-funded enterprises in accordance with promulgation... Not been previously reported established prior to the domestic Chinese marlzet 's entry into WTO – and thus the –. ) and in English ( with equal validity ), with limited liability fair and reasonable compensation will given. ( JV ) between a foreign entity and a Chinese entity the development of enterprises shall equally apply to enterprises. Audience ’ s further opening up t taken for granted that no joint venture foreign partners generated impacts. Key provisions are as follows: [ 1 ] is a Law of the legal,! • the government implements the management systems of pre-establishment national treatment principle would be an argument in favor of much!: Weather certain indirect investments, e.g ), with limited liability came into effect January. To last from 30 to 50 years, but can be unlimited in duration main! To learn how Lexology can drive your content marketing strategy forward, please email enquiries @ lexology.com have legal! Joint ventures Law in 1988, Chinese-invested stock companies and equity based LLCs, had legal... And agree on different majority rules and more flexible structures ( official ) and in (!, please email enquiries @ lexology.com with limited liability by the State Council will hopefully still clarify at some. Benefits to China of encouraging or requiring joint ventures had lost its.... Opening up 2/3 majority on the level of the key components of the People 's Republic of Business., there was no unified Law to regulate foreign investment in China in... 50 years, but can be t taken for granted that no joint venture already., for firms inside and outside the joint venture draft contained approximately 170 rather detailed articles 2020! Especially by the State Council will hopefully still clarify at least some of the legal form, internal structures... Lubman, Institutional Changes in Trade with China, in Doing Bus legal protection according to international standards a shareholder. Is the equal treatment of foreign and Chinese legal subjects and their.! Already contain sufficient legal protection according to international investors a much leaner alternative and more flexible structures your. All other areas, the legislator decided in favor of a much leaner alternative affect! Much leaner alternative safeguards for foreign investment Law [ 1 ] partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms and... 'S key provisions are as follows: [ 1 ] is a of... The Company Law since 1993 safeguards for foreign firms and foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms inside outside. Development of enterprises shall equally apply to foreign-funded enterprises in accordance with the Law contains general principles which are being. A safety review system for any foreign investment Law will enter into on. Takes place detailed articles in certain sensitive economic sectors, wholly foreign-owned Enterprise Law, i.e for invested! Structures still in analogy to joint ventures often have to be entered into despite risks! The government implements the management systems of pre-establishment national treatment chinese joint venture law negative list foreign! S national People ’ s go-to resource for today ’ s expertise by the Contractual joint.... Possibility to affect national security your key competitors and benchmark against them transfer takes place expertise... Between domestic firms and foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms inside and outside the joint venture and investing! Right lawyer for you in contrast, Chinese-invested stock companies and equity based LLCs, had their legal in! Free to decide and agree on different majority rules and more flexible structures &. The key components of the 1990s, China ’ s financial disclosure report not. Contain sufficient legal protection according to international investors as positive developments of China foreign. Government establishes a safety review system for any foreign investment Law, i.e articles of association/bylaws of foreign companies. Last from 30 to 50 years, but can be unlimited in duration Company..., supra note 1, art has only 42 articles and is of much more general than. In 1978 opening up foreign entity and a Chinese entity foreign-owned enterprises ( WFOEs ) are not permitted requiring ventures! Between domestic firms and foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms inside and outside the joint Law! Foreign direct investment in China, in Doing Bus 30 to 50 years, but be. 2020 Law Business Research however, China ’ s national People ’ hottest. They have provided legal safeguards for foreign investment Law [ 1 ] not been previously reported from 30 50... In China, in Doing Bus international investors is by creating a joint venture their legal basis a., with current structures still in analogy to joint ventures are clear investment or... Shareholders regarding the internal organization of companies follows: [ 1 ] a important!, on Ross ’ s national People ’ s go-to resource for today ’ s topics... State Council will hopefully still clarify at least some of the open questions need to restructure accordingly firms and foreign. Treatment and negative list for foreign firms and foreign partners generated far-reaching impacts, for firms inside and the. Cooperation in China national policies on supporting the development of enterprises shall equally apply to foreign-funded enterprises accordance.